The Canes got out to a two-goal lead in the first period courtesy of goals from Jack Roslovic (18) and Sebastian Aho (16) but failed to find the net the rest of the way.
Alexander Romanov (1) scored his first goal of the season before veteran Anders Lee (21) tied it up in the third period to send it to overtime where Brock Nelson (15) sent home the game-winner.
New York has now won four straight games, their longest of the season, and have now jumped the Pittsburgh Penguins in the Metropolitan Division. Meanwhile, the win for the Isles ended the Canes' four-game win streak.
Devils 4-3 Canadiens
Jack Hughes (19) scored a breakaway game-winning goal in overtime for the Devils after the Canadiens scored two straight in the third period to send it into overtime. Despite the devastating loss for Montreal, goaltender Jakub Dobes still had himself a night saving 40 of 44 shots from the Devils.
After losing four straight, the Devils have now won back-to-back games. Meanwhile, the Canadiens have now lost two straight and three of their last five games. The two teams will face each other again for another round in Montreal on February 8th.
Flames 5-4 Wild
The Flames held off the Wild after they scored three goals in the third period. Andrei Kuzmenko (4) led the way with two goals en route to Calgary's third straight win and fourth of the last six games. This is also their second win over the Wild this season in both matchups
Meanwhile, Minnesota has now lost back-to-back games and four of their last six as they continue to slide in the Central Division standings. The two teams will face off in their third and final matchup of the season series on April 11th.
Around the league
Kirill Marchenko scored his 20th goal of the season at the perfect time, sending one home to give the Columbus Blue Jackets a 3-2 overtime win over the Los Angeles Kings to extend their win streak to three games.
The Colorado Avalanche dropped their third straight after a 3-1 loss to the Boston Bruins while the Edmonton Oilers took home a 3-2 win over the Buffalo Sabres, going 2-1 during Connor McDavid's three-game suspension.
The Seattle Kraken have now won three of their last four after a 4-1 win over the Pittsburgh Penguins. Cam Talbot made 28 saves in the Red Wings 2-0 win over Tampa Bay Lightning, marking his 33rd career NHL shutout.
Ottawa also put the clamps on the Toronto Maple Leafs for a 2-1 victory. The Senators have now won four of their last five while the Leafs have now dropped back-to-back games, scoring only one goal in each.